Modi 2.0 fulfils BJP’s core agenda in first year, but Covid-19 throws new challenges

The Modi government executed its ideological agenda at a vigorous pace in its first year in office in its second term, but the economic devastation wrought by Covid-19 has presented the saffron dispensation with a massive challenge as the focus shifts to economy.

With the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance government marking its first anniversary on Saturday, the first year is likely to be remembered for the fulfilment of decades-old Hindutva demands as Prime Minister Narendra Modi used the huge majority his party won in the 2019 Lok Sabha polls to push through its core agenda.

Many achievements

The nullification of Article 370, which gave the erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir special status, and the construction of Ram temple in Ayodhya have been the two key ideological highlights of the BJP’s manifestoes over the decades, and both were settled in its favour in the last one year.

Article 370 was nullified by the government with Parliament passing a resolution to this effect as well in August, and the State was bifurcated into union territories.

An order from a constitutional bench of the Supreme Court paved the way for the construction of the temple at the place in Ayodhya where Lord Ram was believed to have been born.

It was a sign of the perceived popular acceptance of the Hindutva agenda that many of its key issues — which once made the BJP a pariah for most parties and forced it to keep them away to win allies in the late 90s — drew support from even non-NDA parties in Parliament.

CAA controversy

The BJP succeeded in criminalising the practice of triple talaq among Muslims and successfully pushed through both houses of Parliament the contentious Citizenship (Amendment) Act.

BJP vice president Vinay Sahasrabuddhe told PTI that the completion of the first year of Modi 2.0 is all about keeping promises. “It’s also about three Cs: Conviction, Courage and Commitment. The first stint was about effective implementation of welfare schemes that yielded remarkable results,” he said, noting that the move on the Article 370 and the CAA was “very natural” after the BJP received a “renewed and extended” mandate in 2019.

The passage of CAA, which seeks to grant citizenship to non-Muslims from three neighbouring Muslim majority countries on the ground of religious persecution, prompted intense protests, promoting the prime minister to assert that his government has not discussed any move to implement the National Register of Citizens.

Opposition parties and social groups have argued that the NRC in conjunction with the CAA can be discriminatory.

Covid impact

As Covid-19 ravages lives across the country, forcing reverse-migration of the poor in huge numbers, claiming employment in millions and posing health as well as economic challenges, the pandemic has been dominating the public discourse and posing new challenges to the government.

Sahasrabuddhe says the government and the BJP have been fighting the challenge of Covid-19 with remarkable courage. The discourse on “Atmanirbhar Bharat”, he says referring to Modi’s call for a self-reliant India to deal with the Covid-19 crisis, is all about our commitment to “antyodaya” (uplift of the most poor). “Conversion of a challenge to an opportunity is the way ahead, making it the fourth C,” he says.

During the relatively muted anniversary celebrations by the party, its organisational efforts under its president JP Nadda and the Modi government’s measures to address the adverse fallout of Covid-19 will be at the centre of its outreach.

Underperforming in polls

Home Minister Amit Shah, who shifted to the government after leading the party in the general elections, emerged as the second most visible and powerful voice of the government as he piloted its decisions related to Jammu and Kashmir, and the CAA among others. Veteran BJP leader Nadda took over the helm of the party from Shah in January.

While the BJP’s ideological juggernaut rolled on with an unprecedented vigour, the electoral rewards have been less than encouraging for the party, marking the continuation of a trend that has seen it underperforming in state assembly polls compared to Lok Sabha elections.

With “Modi factor” not at work, the party’s performance was seen below par in Maharashtra, where its traditional ally Shiv Sena joined hands with opposition parties to form the government, and Haryana, where it had to ally with a regional party to secure a majority.

The BJP suffered a big defeat in Jharkhand, where it was in power, and fared poorly in its bid to remove Arvind Kejriwal-led AAP from power in Delhi.

However, the party did manage to turn the tables in Karnataka and Madhya Pradesh as defections from rival parties installed veteran saffron warhorses BS Yediyurappa and Shivraj Singh Chouhan as chief minister in the two states respectively.

Though Covid-19 has raised certain uncertainties about polling processes, the next round of electoral challenge the party will face is Bihar assembly polls, which are slated for October-November, followed by elections in West Bengal, Kerala, Assam, Tamil Nadu and Puducherry in the first half of next year.

How the Centre and the respective state governments dealt with enormous challenges the coronavirus posed, will likely weigh heavily in people’s mandate.