EU chief von der Leyen to propose €1 trillion coronavirus recovery fund

It comes after Germany and France proposed a €500 billion fund instead of coronabonds – but it’s still not clear if the funds will be loans or grants.

EUROPEAN UNION CHIEF Ursula von der Leyen is to propose a roughly trillion-euro post-virus recovery fund for Europe, but will have to win over sceptical member states.

This is an extra €500 billion on top of the €540 billion already announced as part of the EU bailout fund and other fiscal packages.

There is a row over whether the funds should be loans or grants: the frugal four – Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden -  are against joint-debt and prefer loans, while Italy and Spain argue that more loans wouldn’t go far to helping them in this crisis.

The global coronavirus outbreak has thrust the EU into its deepest ever recession, and Von der Leyen’s proposal will set out to help the worst affected countries.

The virus has killed at least 172,000 people in Europe and put its economy in a deep freeze, with businesses only slowly reopening and tight controls on borders that were once wide open for travel and trade.

Italy and Spain were Europe’s first victims of the outbreak and, still burdened with heavy debts, lack the firepower of Germany and others to rebuild their shattered economies.

The European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, has won the crucial backing of Germany and France to raise €500 billion on financial markets to begin to fix the problem.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel dropped a bombshell last week by approving an idea that partly reverses Berlin’s staunch opposition to joint borrowing by EU members.

Merkel, who is in the final years of a long stint as German chancellor, also backs the EU helping virus-struck countries with grants rather than loans, another policy U-turn by Berlin.

But the French-German plan faces a counter-proposal from the so-called Frugal Four: northern EU member states who have traditionally opposed giving more cash to Brussels or transferring it to the indebted south.

They firmly oppose paying out aid in grants, preferring loans that come with stern conditions and outside oversight, and reduce risk to their own taxpayers.

They also accuse southern Europeans of living beyond their means and piling on debt instead of choosing fiscal reform.

‘Strong infighting’

The grants versus loans debate is no small matter, with Italy, Greece and Spain already crippled by mountains of debt, despite embarking on painful reforms since the 2008 financial crisis.

European Central Bank Vice-President Luis de Guindos yesterday warned that more debts incurred by countries already under pressure could spook the markets and endanger the euro single currency.

The European Central Bank (ECB) strongly backs joint borrowing by the EU to check that threat.

#Open journalism No news is bad news Support The Journal
Your contributions will help us continue to deliver the stories that are important to you
Support us now

Janis Emmanouilidis, of the Brussels-based think tank European Policy Center, said the French-German proposal, “makes it difficult for others to resist compromise.”

Still, given the frugals’ approach, “you just know how far away we’re still from an EU-27 compromise … strong infighting is ahead,” he said.

A top EU official said that Von der Leyen’s compromise would propose about one trillion euros through a mix of grants and loans.

Von der Leyen will first deliver the plan to the European Parliament before hosting a news conference and then devote the next weeks and months to tough negotiations with EU nations and MEPs.

Diplomats predict talks could drag on until at least July, while experts do not expect an agreement before September – when Germany has taken over the rotating EU presidency.

Financing the plan could take even longer as it would require ratification by national parliaments across all EU member states – typically a risky process.

Von der Leyen’s commission has already delivered more modest recovery aid, including insurance for strained partial employment schemes as well as suspending rules on running up national deficits

The 19 countries that use the euro single currency have already made available €540 billion in loan guarantees for emergency health spending.